First Person(Emma Hawke):
What is being communicated?
It appears to be communicating forest fires, the bright coloured tree looks like its on fire however it also looks like its simply changing colours in the season
Is it clear?
Fairly clear, could be a bit more obvious though. The second image I had to do a fair amount of looking around to find the link to the last page
Does it answer the brief?
Yes it does.
How might it be improved?
(sorry, this may end up being long)
Starting off, I would suggest adding smoke in the first image, this will help guid the eye much better to the burning tree however it will also make it more clear that the tree is on fire and that the leaves aren’t just dying. That is what needs to be improved on the first image. second one I suggest working a little more on cleaning up the branches as white spaces are visible when the clouds darken, which brings me to my next point. The clouds don’t loop smoothly, this gives a jarring experience. To fix this I suggest that you have a small section of just empty sky on either side of the image, this may help fixing this and prevent attention being pulled away from where it needs to be, the tree in the centre of the image. I would also suggest having everything but that tree greyscale, maybe use a layer mask with a greyscale adjustment layer to remove the colours from everything. Upping the contrast of just the tree could also help with this.
Second Person(Cameron):
What is being communicated?
It was a bit difficult to tell at first and needed some explanation. Essentially it is on how the Witcher creator is suing the game company. It also has a link to his wiki.
Is it clear?
Not at all
Does it answer the brief?
Not entirely
Can it be improved?
Finding a less pixelated of the creator would be a good start. Finding ways to bring focus to certain areas would also be a good idea. For example, remove the thing in the top and have the guy clearer. Desaturate the background then adding some animation, doesn’t have to be major.
Third Person(Emma Clarke):
What is being communicated?
Animal adoption, funny and cute dogs as well as a list of dog breed
Is it clear?
Fairly clear, would be clearer if the second image wasn’t so big
Does it answer the brief?
Yes it does
Can it be improved?
To start with, the second image is too large, maybe export it smaller. The first animation would be better if it looped smoother. The dog’s head also tilts a bit too far and thus makes it rather unnatural, tilting it a bit less would make it less unnerving
Fourth Person(Aaron):
What is being communicated?
A specific view on choices within World Of Warcraft, specifically which team you join
Is it clear?
Not entirely, focus is difficult especially on second image
Does it answer the brief?
Partially, no visible animation
Can it be improved?
Decrease the size of the second image. Add some animation, perhaps a glow?
Other people’s reviews+my responses
Review(Emma Hawke):
What is being communicated?
This series of webpages encourage the user to interact with them in order to lead the user to the artist’s channel at the end. This could be a way of promoting the Scarlett Rose’s work or encouraging others to listen to her music.
Response:
This is what I was aiming for.
Is it clear?
I think the message is very clear from the start as the first webpage features artwork with is specifically drawn to match Rose’s style. The name of the webpage also pertains to one of her songs — ‘Melody of a Murderer’. The second page also features a flattering picture of Scarlett Rose, again, promoting her work and not criticising it.
Response:
Same as previous statement
Does it answer the brief?
I think this interactive webpage answers the brief as the first page has an animated GIF witch catches the user’s attention and keeps their focus on the part of the page which is a working link. The second webpage also relates to both the subject matter and first webpage, keeping true to the website’s theme. The second webpage contains a working link to Scarlett Rose’s YouTube channel. This ties the work together nicely as as he has been the continuous theme throughout the webpages and is the overall inspiration for the work.
Response:
The initial plan was to have the link lead to the the song that inspired the artwork however I decided against this
Can it be improved?
Though the website is compete on its own, you might want to consider experimenting with adding sound to one or more of the webpages as Scarlett Rose’s channel largely revolves around music. You could also incorporate lyrics in the form of typography and try out different fonts. This could give your work an additional message or keep it in theme with the gothic aesthetic.
Response:
I will take this into consideration. At one point in time I did consider placing lyrics however I chose not to do this as this would draw attention away from where I wanted.
Review(Dan):
What is being communicated?
2 slender looking people ball room dancing with a 3d overlay with the link going to the youtube Scarlett rose
Response:
Not entirely sure what you are saying here
Is it clear?
The inspiration is clear however from my perspective not knowing the youtube and the significance of how the two merge is not clear from my point of view
Response:
I am not sure what you mean by this, what I had attempted to do was give a feel of Scarlett’s music without needing the audio
Does it answer the brief?
Yes
Response:
Ok?
Can it be improved?
Not from what I can see.
Response:
Thank you
Review(Emma Clarke):
What is being communicated?
Something to do with dancing and singing.
Response:
That is sort of correct, it is bringing attention to a specific music artist
Is it clear?
I think it’s clear at first that it’s either going to be about dancing/singing but the second page doesn’t make it very clear what it’s about.
Response:
The second image is the artist of the music, its meant to show the viewer who this musical artist is.
Does it answer the brief?
It does answer the brief by being interactive.
Response:
No response needed
Can it be improved?
Make it a bit clearer about what it’s supposed to be about (referring to second image).
Response:
I can try add her name? Although I feel this would ruin the feel of the image
Review(Aaron):
What is being communicated?
you should watch Scarlett Rose on youtube
Response:
Is it clear?
I guess
Response:
You guess? That is really helpful
Does it answer the brief?
it might do
Response:
No response
Can it be improved?
probably, do more
Response:
A little more information would help. I need to know what I can do